Matt Fradd
Spirituality/Belief • Books • Writing
St. Faustina & The Divine Mercy Controversy
February 22, 2024
post photo preview

The following article was actually a post by one of our Locals' supporters, Cody Hayes, back on December 2, 2022. I just now came across it and thought it was really well written. I wanted to post it as an article here so more people could read it. Thank you, Cody!

 


 

Lately I’ve become intrigued by investigating the areas of correlation between the western reverence to Jesus' Sacred Heart and the eastern concept of "prayer of the heart" the Jesus prayer and nous, as well as exploring whether the Divine Mercy chaplet may somehow unite these two treasured devotions.

I've been considering how St. Faustina, her writings, the Divine Mercy chaplet, the original Divine Mercy image, etc., are this synthesis of east and west, just as Poland (the location of the apparitions) and Lithuania (where Sr. Faustian received formation) are the gateways to both worlds and cultures.

It appears that all schools of thought and expression are equally represented in the devotion of Faustina. The chaplet is extremely reminiscent of the Jesus prayer; it even closes with the Trisagion, a hymn sung at Divine Liturgy in the majority of Eastern rites. However, it also incorporates elements of the Sacred Heart devotion and rosary.

The original Divine Mercy artwork is both Western, and yet, very reminiscent of eastern iconography. You can perceive it if you are thinking about icons while viewing the Divine Mercy image, and you can also in paradoxical like fashion detect it if you are thinking about Western depictions of Christ. Due to the fact that it does not explicitly depict the Sacred Heart, the image of Divine Mercy is more agreeable to eastern devotional sensibilities. For this reason I am convinced that the Divine Mercy devotions are more approachable to eastern Christians, or at least more approachable to them than the Sacred Heart depictions or various western Marian devotions.

The chapel housing the miraculous icon of Our Lady of Ostrabrama, which is revered by both Catholics and Orthodox, is where the very first Divine Mercy image was unveiled in front of the lay faithful. Remarkably, the name "Our Lady of Mercy" was given to the icon years before Saint Faustina started to receive revelations of Divine Mercy. Additionally, when praying a novena in the Ostrabrama chapel the icon came to life and spoke to Saint Faustina. This is why an image of the Ostrabrama icon is frequently shown in older pamphlets that promoted the devotion to Divine Mercy. The Byzantine rite was one Saint Faustina was familiar with. On more than one occasion, she attended a retreat that had a Divine Liturgy, this according to a footnote in her diary.

The diary of Faustina is filled with eastern practicality and is incredibly mysterious and mystical. However, it is also framed according to traditional Catholic doctrinal principles. All of these factors occasionally come under harsh criticism from various western traditionalist groups, but in my opinion, what they are really objecting to is a foreign ‘easterness’ rather than liberalism or modernism. (More about this later…)

Given that there are both Orthodox and Catholics living thereabouts in that region, perhaps this unique Divine Mercy devotion is merely a reminder of how the church once functioned organically, breathing from both lungs, before the great schism, and what it might once more embody, God willing.

However, the Eastern Orthodox aren’t the only skeptics of this recent (and controversial) Roman Catholic devotion. Amongst various online traditionalist circles, I have witnessed vast criticisms of St. Faustina and the Divine Mercy devotions. Granted I have never met anyone in real life who holds this position and I attend traditional liturgies exclusively. Most of these folks are on Internet COM boxes and have these generic criticisms:

1. Sister Faustina’s diary was put on the index of forbidden books. Within the diary there are perplexing, confusing, uncanny events recorded.

2. The original Divine Mercy image commissioned by Sister Faustina does not have the wounds of Christ.

3. Devotion to the Divine Mercy image and chaplet of Divine Mercy take away the rightful attention to the Sacred Heart image and Holy Rosary.

Personally, I think these arguments are weak and intellectually flawed. But actually, it’s not even that big of a deal- if you don’t like the Divine Mercy image, diary, or chaplet, then don’t participate in them. They’re optional.

1. Sister Faustina’s diary was put on the index of forbidden books. Within the diary there are perplexing, confusing, uncanny events recorded.

The typical explanation of this is that there was a faulty translation and the Vatican made this decision based off of this translation. John Paul II, being from Poland, personally took up arms for the corrected translation argument and rehabilitated this private revelation. JPII is by far not my favorite Papacy and it seems, in hindsight, he made a lot of poor prudential judgments-especially in matters ecumenism. But I don’t think rehabilitating the Divine Mercy was one of them. Karol Wojtyła was a holy, pious, and a remarkable intellectual; Polish was his native tongue and he spoke 12 other languages. If he said that it was a translation error, then it’s safe to say that I can trust him on that. The opposition to this position, has to reach very far ideologically speaking and use Pope John the 23rd as proof. St Faustina‘s diary and devotion were still banned under the pontificate of John XXIII ... but half of these claimants don’t even believe he was a true pope.

Within the diary there are perplexing, confusing, uncanny events recorded. Yup. Every single apparition I have ever read is the same. That’s why they are private revelations and not public revelations. The diary is huge. And just because it is approved doesn’t mean that every single word is true. Faustina could’ve made a mistake while transcribing it. It’s not divinely inspired. That said, it is a beautiful read, full of orthodox teachings. One cannot mistake that Sister Faustina loves our Lord, His Sacred Heart, the Church, His Mother, and is fearful of His Divine Justice.

Apparitions are private revelations and do not add nor complete the deposit of revelation found in Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition. You can take them or leave them and still be a faithful, orthodox, and traditional practicing catholic. Even if the Church does give an official approval to a private revelation, the faithful are not obliged to believe in it.

I have observed, especially in traditional circles, an unhealthy focus on private revelations. They interpret everything: scripture, sacred tradition, magisterial teaching, through this ‘hermeneutic of apparition’. It reminds me of similar circles of Protestantism that interpret all of the Bible through they’re understanding of the book of revelation.

It should actually be the opposite, we should spend more time focusing on Scripture, Church fathers, encyclicals, the writings of saints. Those are our meat and potatoes. Private revelations are dessert. You can eat dessert first and more frequently but you will get cavities, obesity, and heart disease. And boy there are some unhealthy fat kid internet trolls out there!

2. The original Divine Mercy image commissioned by Sister Faustina does not have the wounds of Christ.

Recently I purchased an exclusive licensed and commissioned hi-resolution digital replica of St. Faustina’s original masterpiece of the Divine Mercy painted by Eugeniusz Kazimirowski 1935 in Vilnius, Lithuania. This is not simply a copy or a picture of the work. What appears to be wounds can be seen on the hands, granted they aren’t front and center nor are they specifically highlighted. But one can see them for sure. Keep in mind that this image was not completely found and restored until 2000. Everything you can find on the internet is simply a low quality picture.

Again, this is a private revelation and even if the Vatican does approve the image, it only says that it is not harmful and that one can venerate it if one wishes, all be it prudently. If you don’t like the image – don’t make it part of your spiritual devotional life. Catholics are free to choose which devotions or type of art they like. There are also some complaints that the image does not show our Lord’s most Sacred Heart. Com'on where do you think the rays are flowing from?

3. Devotion to the Divine Mercy image and chaplet of Divine Mercy take away the rightful attention to the Sacred Heart image and holy rosary.

This is silly. Reciting the rosary takes twenty minutes. Reciting the Divine Mercy chaplet takes less than ten. Somebody can’t do both in a single day? In my household, the Sacred Heart of Jesus is enthroned...and in another part of the house I have a picture of the Divine Mercy prominently hung. I’ve never met a devotee of the Divine Mercy message that didn’t also have some devotion to the Sacred Heart. If they didn’t, that’s cool too. It’s optional.

Again, you don’t have to promote or participate in every single Catholic devotion. I can freely choose the chotki over the rosary. I can pray the luminous mysteries, I don’t personally, but I totally could and still be a traditional Catholic. I can choose to wear the green scapular and not the brown. I can choose to wear St. Benedict Medal and not the Miraculous. Or I can choose none of them. They’re optional.

I think that people, well-meaning people, have received specific favors from specific devotions and then they become passionate about their own personal devotional piety. They then become crypto-superstitious evangelists so to speak, ruthlessly proselytizing others to pick up the mantle of their personal taste and experience. As Cardinal Arinze used to say, ‘people should be left in peace and not in pieces’. If someone has a devotional life, THAT IS AWESOME, that means that they are praying. Cool. Amen.

I'm not a 'Radical-Traditionalist' just because pray the 15 mysteries exclusively. I'm not a 'Neo-Catholic' just because I recite the Divine Mercy Chaplet. I don't belong to the 'Church of Nice' just because I'm non-confrontational and well... nice. I'm just a mass going, magisterium following, tradition loving, Catholic who is fighting for sanctity in this unprecedented time. Let’s stop being knee-jerk reactionaries and let’s stop being jerks in general.

I believe that the Divine Mercy devotions are more palatable to Protestant sensibilities too. I’ve gotten my Protestant friends to say the Chaplet of Divine Mercy more easily than the rosary. But then from there they can warm-up to the rosary. They seem to be attracted to the image as well when Protestants are usually somewhat squeamish at Catholic imagery.

One day, towards the last few years of my mom’s life, she called me up and asked me, “what’s that one song prayer thing they sing on TV everyday?”

Me perplexed and annoyed, “huh!?”

She responded like I should certainly know, “you know they sing EVERY afternoon.”

Me in the middle of a lunch rush, “Mom I’m at work, who sings a song?”

Mom starts singing off key, “for the sake of His sorrowful passion.”

I walk to the office stunned, “mom that’s the Divine Mercy chaplet. You watch EWTN the Catholic station?”

Like a happy child she exclaimed, “yeah I like that song prayer thing- I listen everyday.” Her off key song resumes, “Have mercy on us and on the whole world.”

“Ok Mom, love you, got to get back to work.”

“I love you son, say it again.”

“Love you mom.”

If my mother, a former assemblies of God charismatic baptistish woman can learn, recite daily, and find great peace in the Chaplet of Divine Mercy...then anyone can! I pray this prayer was on her lips and heart in her last moments.

Jesus, I trust in You.

community logo
Join the Matt Fradd Community
To read more articles like this, sign up and join my community today
24
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
You Can Always Offer Something - Fr. Gregory Pine, O.P.

Sometimes we have it in our mind that we need to offer the Lord a perfect gift of ourselves if it's going to count for something. Aware of our various attachments and imperfections, we put off making the gift until such time as we are in a position to make a more pleasing sacrifice. My counsel to you is to offer what you have at present, even if it's imperfect. Because that's the git you actually have and that's the gift in which the Lord actually delights : )

Here's the link for the book: https://www.amazon.com/Your-Eucharistic-Identity-Sacramental-Fullness/dp/162164796X/ref=sr_1_1?crid=1SME6J5KYKVXI&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.HRZlgfwsmxjGFj1ePRw-OgluBhzhKL7XiQCNKyHEK_s.V0RluCVNmFRjkIZWue1otfyktDPiZN_QnWrjE_LTPtU&dib_tag=se&keywords=your+eucharistic+identity+gregory+pine&qid=1755616701&sprefix=your+eucharistic%2Caps%2C94&sr=8-1

00:19:19
The Tide is Turning - Fr. Gregory Pine, O.P.

I just got back from five weeks of preaching and travels which took me to Australia and Italy. I have been super encouraged by what I have seen in these days, especially by the interest in the faith and the desire on the part of young people to follow the Lord Jesus. It might just be that the tide of secularization is turning in the developed world.

00:19:48
Further Thoughts on the TLM - Fr. Gregory Pine, O.P.

With recent announcements in Charlotte and Detroit, it feels like old wounds are getting re-opened. This video provides a couple of principles and arguments that can help think through and pray though liturgical life in 2025.

00:25:05
Simple NEW Lofi Song

Working on an entire album of lofi music. Here's one of those songs. Album should drop next week. THEN, a couple of weeks after that we hope to have our 24/7 stream up and running.

Simple NEW Lofi Song
December 01, 2022
Day 5 of Advent

THE ERROR OF ARIUS ABOUT THE INCARNATION

In their eagerness to proclaim the unity of God and man in Christ, some heretics went to the opposite extreme and taught that not only was there one person, but also a single nature, in God and man. This error took its rise from Arius. To defend his position that those scriptural passages where Christ is represented as being inferior to the Father, must refer to the Son of God Himself, regarded in His assuming nature, Arius taught that in Christ there is no other soul than the Word of God who, he maintained, took the place of the soul in Christ’s body. Thus when Christ says, in John 14:28, “The Father is greater than I,” or when He is introduced as praying or as being sad, such matters are to be referred to the very nature of the Son of God. If this were so, the union of God’s Son with man would be effected not only in the person, but also in the nature. For, as we know, the unity of human nature arises from the union of soul and body.

The...

Day 5 of Advent
November 27, 2022
Day 1 of Advent

RESTORATION OF MAN BY GOD THROUGH THE INCARNATION

We indicated above that the reparation of human nature could not be effected either by Adam or by any other purely human being. For no individual man ever occupied a position of pre-eminence over the whole of nature; nor can any mere man be the cause of grace. The same reasoning shows that not even an angel could be the author of man’s restoration. An angel cannot be the cause of grace, just as he cannot be man’s recompense with regard to the ultimate perfection of beatitude, to which man was to be recalled. In this matter of beatitude angels and men are on a footing of equality. Nothing remains, therefore, but that such restoration could be effected by God alone.

But if God had decided to restore man solely by an act of His will and power, the order of divine justice would not have been observed. justice demands satisfaction for sin. But God cannot render satisfaction, just as He cannot merit. Such a service pertains to one who ...

Day 1 of Advent

Ecclesiastes 1:2

3:38 a.m.

A ‘midnight feast’ as she calls it.

We sat at the little table in the dim light,
savoring off-brand Cinnamon Toast Crunch,
plotting to steal fairy snores
so we could finally find sleep.

Core memory for her.
Long Monday for me.

Tomorrow will be another random Monday,
corporate chatter,
deadlines stacked like paper idols,
forgotten in months,
Deleted in years.

It’s only Monday for me.
But it’s her childhood.

And I got to be there. Me.

The moment our children take their first breaths,
we become the ghosts of their memories.
The stories they’ll pass down.

We can be saints.
We can be villains.
Most of us drift between both.
So: choose your cereal wisely.

Repent.
Repair.
Then sit down and play.

Metanoia.
Mentor.
Communion.

3:48 a.m.
And I’m still smiling.

For all my fragile existence,
this is where I’ve been placed,
amid cinnamon-sugar, corn-puff absurdities,
chemical-unnatural-deliciousness,
and the giggles of a five-year-old.

This is what wealth looks like.
Not monetary millions,
but the cosmic lottery.

Out of billions galaxies,
out of all the centuries,
this is...

post photo preview

Quote of the Day
"It is the duty of every man to uphold the dignity of every woman."
Pope St. John Paul II

Today's Meditation
“Above all, it is necessary to ask of God every morning the gift of perseverance, and to beg of the Blessed Virgin to obtain it for you, and particularly in the time of temptation, by invoking the name of Jesus and Mary as long as the temptation lasts. Happy the man who will continue to act in this manner, and shall be found so doing when Jesus Christ shall come to judge him. ‘Blessed is that servant, whom, when his Lord shall come, he shall find so doing’ (Matt. 24:46).”
—St. Alphonsus De Liguori, p. 167

Daily Verse
"Thus says the Lord: "Let not the wise man glory in his wisdom, let not the mighty man glory in his might, let not the rich man glory in his riches; but let him who glories glory in this, that he understands and knows me, that I am the Lord who practice steadfast love, justice, and righteousness in the earth; for in these things I delight, says the ...

post photo preview

Today in mass, I saw a guy with his Great Adventure Bible. I usually either bring my Magnificant or my Every Sacred Sunday journal, but I love the idea of bringing my Bible to mass. Does anyone else bring their Bible to mass? If so, do you just find the readings from mass and read those? Just curious how others might use their Bible during mass? My initial thoughts was it would help give content to the mass readings since you have the scripture right there. Help paint a better picture.

post photo preview
33 Days of Preparation for Marian Consecration on Locals – Starts Sept 4

Hey everyone!

Beginning September 4th, our Locals community will enter into 33 days of spiritual preparation for total consecration to Jesus through Mary. 

We will conclude together on October 7th, the Feast of Our Lady of the Holy Rosary.

Here’s how it will unfold on Locals:

- We will be guided by Fr. Boniface Hicks’ beautiful book, The Fruit of Her Womb: 33-Day Preparation for Total Consecration to Jesus Through Mary. (I’ve received special permission from the publisher to share it with Locals members.)

- A daily meditation and prayer will be posted each day for the 33 days.

- To accompany us, Fr. Boniface will provide several exclusive videos recorded just for Locals, offering guidance and encouragement along the way.

This is an opportunity to consecrate—or renew your consecration—to Jesus through Mary in the company of a prayerful community, with the wisdom of a priest who has written deeply on this devotion.

Mark your calendar: We begin September 4th.

You can purchase a copy of the book here: https://www.amazon.com/33-Day-Preparation-Total-Consecration-Through/dp/1644138409

Read full Article
post photo preview
What St. Thomas Means by "Curiosity"

In today's livestream I spoke about the sin of curiosity. In this article, I thought I'd sum it up for you in case I didn't do it well in the livestream.

You can read Thomas' own words here, btw. 

For Aquinas, “curiosity” is not simply the healthy desire to know the truth. He distinguishes between the virtue of studiositas—the ordered pursuit of knowledge—and the vice of curiositas, which is the disordered pursuit of knowledge.

Curiosity becomes a vice when we seek knowledge in the wrong way or for the wrong reasons: for pride, idle speculation, gossip, or knowledge that leads us away from God rather than toward Him. For example, indulging in occult practices, probing into sinful matters for fascination, or prying into things that are none of our business (all of social media, or just most?) are all ways that curiosity corrupts the good of knowledge. In other words, knowledge itself is good, but the way we desire, seek, and use it can be distorted.

Aquinas says that curiosity can show itself in several ways: when someone prefers trivial knowledge over what would truly benefit their soul (c'mon ... this is how many people live their lives), when one seeks knowledge to boast or to sin, when one is distracted by an endless hunger for new information at the expense of wisdom, or when one turns to forbidden sources of knowledge.

By contrast, the virtue of studiousness disciplines the intellect so that we seek truth for its own sake, for God’s glory, and for the service of others. Thus, Aquinas sees curiosity not as the love of learning itself, but as the disorder of that love—an appetite for knowing that forgets the proper end of knowledge, which is to lead us to truth and ultimately to God.

So here's a challenge for you and me: What is one practical way that we can avoid curiosity and grow in studiousness?

Read full Article
post photo preview
A Practical Method For Spiritual Warfare
 
In this article, I want to suggest a powerful, practical method for spiritual warfare—one that I believe will be a game-changer in your everyday life. We'll explore how consistently announcing what is true and renouncing what is false can become a potent weapon, helping you navigate the unseen battles that often manifest as struggles in our thoughts and emotions.
 
At the Catholic Easter Vigil Mass, there is a significant moment where the congregation renews their Baptismal Promises.

In essence, the priest leads the faithful to announce what is true and to renounce what is false.

For the purposes of this article we’ll begin with the questions that invite annunciations. He asks:

"Do you believe in God, the Father almighty, Creator of heaven and earth?"

"Do you believe in Jesus Christ, his only Son, our Lord, who was born of the Virgin Mary, suffered death and was buried, rose again from the dead and is seated at the right hand of the Father?"

"Do you believe in the Holy Spirit, the holy Catholic Church, the communion of saints, the forgiveness of sins, the resurrection of the body, and life everlasting?"

In responding “I do” to these questions, we are in a very real sense aligning ourselves with reality. While emotions may be present, they don’t need to be. Simply stating our agreement with the way things are is enough.

Prior to the above questions are a series of questions which invite renunciation:

"Do you renounce sin, so as to live in the freedom of the children of God?"

"Do you renounce the lure of evil, so that sin may have no mastery over you?"

"Do you renounce Satan, the author and prince of sin?"

In responding “I do” to these questions, we are renouncing, repudiating, what is false.

To those who may attend Holy Mass once or twice a year they may be surprised to discover just how seriously the Church takes the reality of the Devil and spiritual warfare. But anyone somewhat familiar with the Scriptures and the consistent teaching of the Church would not be. Here I could dump a multitude of Scriptural verses proving my point, but one will suffice. From the first letter of St. Peter:

"Be sober-minded; be watchful. Your adversary the devil prowls around like a roaring lion, seeking someone to devour. Resist him, firm in your faith, knowing that the same kinds of suffering are being experienced by your brotherhood throughout the world."

And now for the main point of this article: Just as it is beneficial to regularly align ourselves with what is true (say through an act of faith), it is also beneficial to regularly repudiate, and disassociate with, what is false.

And given that our lives are situated squarely within a world at war. A world which “lies in the power of the evil one.” in which demonic forces are seeking to blind us to the things of God (2 Cor. 4:4). This is something we are going to be needing to do in one form or another on a daily basis. Multiple times a day.

Let me offer a personal anecdote that will illustrate this. I was about to interview someone on a topic that I knew would get blowback from the Demonic realm. I was going on a walk praying my rosary before my guest arrived. While I was walking I slowly became aware of a sort of oppressive force. I felt sad and restricted, somehow. Anxious. I’m not sure how long I was feeling that way, but at any rate I didn’t become conscious of it until that moment. I stopped walking and tried to sum up what I was experiencing in a word. It clicked. intimidation. That’s was it. I felt intimidated. And so I said the following prayer:

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals