I recently posted this quotation from Pope Paul VI to Youtube:
āFurthermore, in her rejection of every persecution against any man, the Church, mindful of the patrimony she shares with the Jews and moved not by political reasons but by the Gospel's spiritual love, decries hatred, persecutions, displays of anti-Semitism, directed against Jews at any time and by anyone.ā
And, oh man, was the feedback fun. Within minutes, I was accused of everything from cozying up to The Daily Wire to desperately chasing subscribers toāand maybe I shouldnāt be surprisedābeing under the influence of Jewish money.
But one question kept coming up: What is antisemitism? One commenter put it this way:
āHow about having a clear definition of what the word means? Is that too much to ask? Because quite frankly, every time I look it up, it's never really clear. Words have meaning. Or at least they should. If the M word for taking a life was used, and someone is accused of it, everyone knows what it means. But imagine it's not clear what it means. And someone out of nowhere accused someone of it, but the definition keeps changing or is not clearāwhat then?ā
Fair enough. So, to help clarify, Iāve written a Socratic dialogue exploring what I antisemitism isāand what it isnāt.
One quick note before you read onāI assure you, Iām writing this in good faith. I know this topic is deeply important to many people, including my fellow Catholics. This article is simply my attempt to articulate what seems obvious to me, not a middle finger at those who disagree.